Posts

Showing posts from March, 2026

Whistleblowing and The Limits of American Secrecy

Image
The United States has a longer tradition of protecting whistleblowers than most Americans realize. As legal scholar Ruth Ann Strickland notes in the First Amendment Encyclopedia , roughly forty federal laws have been passed to shield employees who expose government and corporate wrongdoing, a legislative history that stretches back to the Revolutionary War itself. Yet despite this deep institutional commitment, the government has repeatedly prosecuted the very people these laws were meant to protect, turning a wartime espionage statute into one of the most powerful tools for silencing dissent in American history. The Continental Congress In 1778, the Continental Congress passed what scholars consider the world's first whistleblower protection law, after naval officers Samuel Shaw and Richard Marven exposed their commanding officer, Commodore Esek Hopkins, for torturing British prisoners of war. Congress not only vindicated the officers but also paid for their legal fees. The princi...

Review: Five Star Final (1931)

Image
Mervyn LeRoy's Five Star Final (1931) is not just an old Hollywood movie; it is a direct conversation about the ethical failures that have plagued journalism since the rise of the penny press. The film follows a tabloid newspaper that digs up a decades-old murder case involving a woman who has long since rebuilt her life, purely to boost circulation. The consequences are devastating. For anyone in journalism, the film works almost like a textbook on what happens when a newsroom abandons its responsibility to the public. The most central ethical problem in the film is the complete lack of regard for the people being covered. The editors and reporters at the Gazette never stop to ask whether publishing the story is the right thing to do, they only ask whether it will sell papers. This is the defining sin of yellow journalism, and the film portrays it without any sympathy. The subject of their coverage, Nancy Voorhees, is not a public figure. She poses no threat to the public interest...